On that same long car trip mentioned below, I listened to The 100-Year-Old Secret
by Tracy Barrett. When Xander and Xena's family relocates to London,
these siblings discover that they are direct descendents of Sherlock
Holmes. They are inducted into a secret society and entrusted with a
notebook containing Holmes' unsolved cases . . . some of which have
tantalizing clues that might lead to solutions, even after so many
years!
Sherlock Holmes, always relatively popular, has seen a
resurgence in popularity over the past few years, what with the movies
and the TV series and all. I can think of at least three children's
mystery book series that are in some way related to Holmes. I have to
admit that, while I have enjoyed some of the original Holmes stories and
some of the recent adaptations, I'm not an expert on Holmes trivia, so I
won't comment too much on that aspect of this story. The Holmes angle
in this book mostly serves to tie together a possible series, rather
than playing directly into the details of this particular story.
In
general, the writing in this story was good. The plot was strong, with
enough clues and red herrings to make things interesting. Xena and
Xander are not particularly memorable characters, but they are fine for a
plot-driven mystery. The things that the siblings encounter, and the
actions that they take to uncover clues, are believable -- they are
things that kids could conceivably accomplish. I don't feel any
compulsion to read more books in this series. However, I will certainly
keep this book in mind for when kids come into the library looking for
mysteries.
(Reviewed from an audiobook borrowed through my library system.)
No comments:
Post a Comment