For Darkness Shows the Stars
by Diana Peterfreund is -- wait for it -- a post-apocalyptic Jane
Austen retelling. This was bound to happen eventually, right? But
actually, it's not as bad as it sounds.
Elliott North is a member
of the post-apocalyptic society's ruling class, the Luddites. Not so
many generations ago, the human race was nearly wiped out by scientific
advances involving tampering with human DNA. The Luddites refused to
participate in this trend for religious reasons, and so when the
scientific experimentation went horribly wrong, the Luddites were the
ones who survived with all of their faculties, while children of the
genetically-enhanced became known as the Reduced because of their
extremely limited mental capacities. These Reduced generally ended up as
servants on the estates of wealthy Luddites, who control society and
severely limit scientific experimentation in order to avoid falling into
the trap of earlier generations. Now, in Elliott's time, some of the
children born to the Reduced are known as Posts (Post-Reduction), with
full mental capacities, but they are still part of the servant class.
One of those Posts, Kai, grew up alongside Elliott on her estate. The
two formed a friendship that eventually turned into something more --
but when Kai fled the estate, Elliott remained behind. Since her
mother's death, Elliott had become the only person capable of managing
the estate, while her father and sister cared only for fashion and
pleasure. Then, four years after leaving the North estate, Kai returns
in a company known as the Cloud Fleet. This group of Posts, lead by a
man known as Captain Innovation, travel to nearby islands in search of
pre-Reduction technology that the Luddites will purchase and use, and
they are renting Elliott's grandfather's defunct shipyard in order to
build a larger sailing vessel. Kai, now known as Malakai Wentforth, is
still just as attractive to Elliott -- but he's still just as angry with
her for her refusal to leave her estate. Can the two move past their
misunderstanding, or is their shared history enough to keep them apart
forever?
Austen fans, no doubt, have already recognized the framework of Persuasion
underneath this story's post-apocalyptic trappings. I'm going to admit
that, while I count myself an Austen fan, I'm not one of those fans who
rereads the canon every year or so and can bring to mind every minute
detail. It's been more than ten years since I read Persuasion,
so my knowledge of the original story did not stand in the way of my
enjoyment of this book. I found it generally enjoyable, with a few minor
details to quibble about. I never thought Kai's resentment of Elliott
for staying behind made much sense -- he knew that she was the one
holding everything together, and if she had left all of the people he
grew up around would probably have starved. I also thought there were a
few more loose ends at the end of the book than I would have liked --
not enough that I feel a sequel is inevitable (or even warranted), but
enough to leave me a little bit unsatisfied. Still, I liked the book on
the whole, and would recommend it if the premise intrigues you. Fans of
Austen retellings will enjoy this if they don't mind a little added
sci-fi, and those who have not read Austen's original will still be able
to enjoy both the well-described dystopia and the sweet romance.
(Reviewed from a copy borrowed through my library system.)
No comments:
Post a Comment