Come a Stranger and
A Solitary Blue by Cynthia Voigt are companions to
Homecoming and
Dicey's Song,
which I read last month. They focus on secondary characters from those
first two books, and can be read as standalone works, though I feel they
work best when the reader has the background story of the Tillermans in
mind.
In
Come a Stranger,
we meet Wilhemina Smiths, a spirited young girl -- or, as some people
might say, T-rou-ble. It's the end of fifth grade, and Mina has just
gotten a scholarship to ballet camp up in New England. Dance is all Mina
wants to do, and she's good at it, too -- never mind that all of her
ballet lessons have been in a makeshift garage studio in little
Crisfield, Maryland. That first summer at camp is everything Mina
dreamed it would be . . . even though she can't help but notice that she
is the only dancer of color at the camp. She spends the next year
waiting for camp to roll around again -- but when it does, she finds
that nothing ever stays exactly the same. Her own body has changed, and
dancing is no longer effortless for her. One of her three best dance
camp friends elected not to return, leaving Mina the odd girl out, alone
in a single dorm room. Certain comments and situations rub her the
wrong way -- is that new, or did she just not notice them the summer
before? And when the camp director calls her in to tell her that it just
isn't working out, Mina quietly acquiesces. Since when has Mina Smiths,
T-rou-ble, ever quietly acquiesced to anything? In thinking over the
events of that summer, Mina must learn how to stand up for herself
again, learn what it means to be a minority and how to keep herself from
being shamed and silenced. And she's about to meet Tamer Shipp, a man
who learned that lesson a long time ago . . .
In
A Solitary Blue,
we meet Jeff Greene, who is just a little boy when his mother leaves.
Melody, Jeff's mother, is going off to fight for the rights of animals
and orphans and the environment, to make the world a better place. Jeff
is left alone with his father, a man he thinks of as The Professor, who
doesn't know the first thing about raising a son. Jeff is convinced that
he must do everything he can to keep the household running smoothly in
order not to lose the only parent he has left -- and, for a few years,
he does. Then, one summer, Melody sends word that she wants Jeff to come
visit her. She is living with her grandmother in a big old house in
Charleston, South Carolina. That summer, Jeff and Melody explore the
city together. Melody is learning to play the guitar, and she teaches
Jeff what she knows. Gambo, the family matriarch, tells Jeff stories of
the family's glory days. Jeff's world, already turned upside down by his
mother's abandonment years ago, seems to have righted itself. And even
though Melody changes Jeff's plane ticket for a bus ticket, pockets the
difference, and then sends him home to Baltimore without any money for
food on the trip, Jeff is entirely devoted to Melody. What does it
matter if she never answers his letters? He will write to her once a
week -- it will be his way of exercising chivalry. Jeff is determined to
be Melody's white knight. He saves up money to buy a secondhand guitar
and practices in order to be able to play for her. And the following
summer he goes back to Charleston, dreaming of another idyllic summer.
But when Melody and her boyfriend meet Jeff at the airport, it's clear
that the summer will not be shaping up to Jeff's dreams. Melody has
found a knight, and it's not Jeff. Her boyfriend whisks her out of town
for a week, and then for another week. In the meantime, Jeff is stuck in
the house with two batty great-aunts and Gambo, who has suffered a
stroke and now treats Jeff as an inconvenience rather than a guest of
honor. To get out of the house, Jeff travels to the outskirts of town.
He buys a rowboat and does some waterfront exploring, discovering an
island inhabited by only the local wildlife -- most notably, a single,
ungainly blue heron. When Melody returns, only to tell Jeff that she is
going away again the following day, it is as if she has abandoned him
once again. Jeff returns to Baltimore in despair. Mired in depression,
he lets his grades slide and starts skipping school -- and eventually,
even The Professor is bound to notice something. What Jeff may have
forgotten, though, is that if there's one person in the world who can
understand the effects of Melody's abandonment, that person would be his
father.
These two books have a lot of similarities in structure -- a great
summer experience, followed by a disappointing summer experience, and
well-written characters who must grow and change in response to those
summer experiences. Believe it or not, despite reading both of these
books multiple times, only with this reading did I notice the similarity
of structure between the two! Part of the reason for this, I think, is
because I've never spent a lot of time analyzing the books in a literary
sense. Both books also have the ability to pull me into their world, to
make me fully empathize with the main characters. For instance, Melody
is one of the most loathsome parents in juvenile/young adult literature,
but though the reader can see how she is manipulating Jeff all along,
the reader can also understand why Jeff is so entirely devoted to her --
and I think it's a testament to the power and skill of Voigt's writing
that she is able to walk that fine line.
In short, these are two old favorites, and this is neither the first time nor the last that I will be rereading them.
(Reviewed from my personally purchased copies.)
