Anatomy of a Misfit by Andrea Portes is an angsty YA novel set in a Midwestern high school.
Anika
Dragomir feels like an outsider in her white-bread high school, despite
the fact that she is the third most popular girl in school. Her angst
is exacerbated when nerd-turned-hottie Logan McDonough starts giving her
rides home from school. Anika kind of likes Logan -- okay, really likes
Logan -- but she know that she would get endless flack from Becky, the
top most popular girl, if she were to date outsider Logan. Anika's
romantic troubles are further complicated when THE Jared Kline, possibly
the most popular guy in town, or maybe the state, starts showing an
interest in her. Sure, it's flattering, but is he just a scam artist who
will use her and drop her as soon as he gets bored? And what about
Logan and their sweet, secret romance?
I read this for my book
club, and I foresee some interesting discussion ensuing. Anika's
narrative voice was, to me, really annoying. I had a hard time liking
her, or even relating to her. Despite the title, I didn't see her as a
misfit -- in fact, I began to wonder if the title was supposed to refer
to her, or to Logan (who probably qualifies as a misfit, but we don't
get nearly as much insight into his character as we do into hers). Anika
is a pretty, popular girl from a middle-class family. She has 99
problems, and all of them are first-world problems, mostly caused by her
own bad choices. Okay, so she's a teenager, I can usually look past
that in a YA book. But the writing was not as tight as I would like it
to be. For one thing, the book is interspersed with short chapters, set
apart by being typeset in italics, that are foreshadowing of the book's
final events -- the character is pedaling on a bike, heading toward some
cataclysmic event. I'd have been fine with one chapter like that at the
beginning, or conversely I'd have been fine if each successive
foreshadowing chapter revealed more key details, but they really didn't
reveal anything new or add anything to the story. Also, as we might
surmise, Anika is the one riding the bike in the foreshadowing chapters,
but it's never mentioned in the earlier parts of the story that she
even has a bike. Instead, we get her whining about her long walk
home from school. Hmm, I see a solution here... One more criticism: I
feel like it's just a little bit lazy when authors from my generation
write YA novels and set them in the high school of the '80s or '90s,
especially when there's not a strong reason within the plot for the book
to be set in the present day. Granted, in this case the author mentions
that the book is partially based on her own high-school experience, but
seeing as it is fiction and not memoir, perhaps the pop culture
references and such could have been updated a bit. I can't find a
plot-based reason why the characters are name-checking Madonna and Bruce
Willis instead of Lady Gaga and Orlando Bloom, or whoever kids these
days name-check. Maybe I am being too picky, because the book did grab
me once I got past being irritated at the narrative voice and settled
into the story. I think this will appeal to fans of YA realistic fiction
along the lines of The Perks of Being a Wallflower, but it wasn't really my cup of tea.
(Reviewed from a copy borrowed through my library system.)
No comments:
Post a Comment